25th SEA GAMES, Vientiane, Laos 2009

NgocAnhVn · Senior Member

Which League is better for Asean player come ?

chenko · Veteran Member

Thai league, I think.

The reason why you should watch thai leauge

-- Edited by chenko on Saturday 5th of December 2009 11:43:59 PM

Khmer_idol · Senior Member

Cambodian players have been exported to both leagues...we hope they are exported to the MY and SIN as well....well, V league has been amazing lately...so attractive.....I totally agree with Ngoc as many people say the same.

Date: Dec 6, 2009

V-League (Vietnam League)
More Thai football players play in V-league, such as Thonglao, Sakda...
Kiatisuk will become Hoang Anh Gia Lai's manager after 25th Sea Games finish...
I dont think Vietnam is best foobal national team in the Asean region but Vietnam League is best league for Asean foobal players.

NgocAnhVn · Senior Member

I'm a fan of Liverpool, hihi.
About topic, as I said, V-league or Indo-league are better league for player improve their skill, but if you want to have a slot in there, you must be a skiller, hihi. So, young team is very important

Majapahit Kid · Senior Member

Fr my opinion,Asean footballers shld play at any leagues in Asean.no problem.better players eventuali wil end up playing in Korea or Japan.d best players probably wil horn their skills in Europe.wat do u thk?agree?Asean footballers r all talented.they nid more assistance fr their respective governments.

Baosheng · Senior Member

S.League would a good choice.

BamBoo · Senior Member

NgocAnhVn wrote:

I'm a fan of Liverpool, hihi.
About topic, as I said, V-league or Indo-league are better league for player improve their skill, but if you want to have a slot in there, you must be a skiller, hihi. So, young team is very important

Poor Swan!!! biggrin

kidding kub

romanit · Member

Vietnamese league is the best league in Asean. V-League always have a big fans. There are many foreign players from many countries in the world play in V-League.

Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia · Senior Member

now, I don't know about other Leagues but I think V-League is the best:x

Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia · Senior Member

and I want to see Laos players and Cambodia players play football here

VNatUtrecht · Veteran Member

I am Vietnamese and I think the V-leauge is very competitive and offers good returns to players.

However, I hope that clubs in V-league have a training program for young players as good as that of their counterpart in Thai-league.

Baosheng · Senior Member

Since Laos and Vietnam are brothers..Vietnam should invite Laos players to V.League. =)

Cheers

NgocAnhVn · Senior Member

I think Asean Country should have law to accept 3 or 4 Asean players in a team as local player. So it will have more change to improve talent player in good league..

hoangphuvn · Veteran Member

Don't ask Y V-League is the best in SEA! :>

MedicinEMan · Member

Vietnam The Bast!....

I Cheer You...

Banana · Senior Member

I think S-Leage first
....

V - Leage second.

.....

But next year Thai Leage will be the first

Dicky Cheung · Newbie

Asean Football League Ranking

1. Indonesian Super League
2. S. League
3. Thai Premier League
4. V-League
5. Super League Malaysia

You Shall Decide!

-- Edited by Dicky Cheung on Saturday 12th of December 2009 09:49:32 AM

VNatUtrecht · Veteran Member

Dicky Cheung wrote:

Asean Football League Ranking

1. Indonesian Super League
2. S. League
3. Thai Premier League
4. V-League
5. Super League Malaysia

You Shall Decide!

-- Edited by Dicky Cheung on Saturday 12th of December 2009 09:49:32 AM

Please quote your source or reference for this ranking.

If it is a personal ranking, then I'd have no question.

Baosheng · Senior Member

Asean Football League Ranking

1. S. League
2. Indonesian Super League
3. Thai Premier League
4. V-League
5. Super League Malaysia

Dicky Cheung · Newbie

Google does the magic my friend.

VNatUtrecht · Veteran Member

Well, it depends on the validity of the source.

I tried Google but could not find a valid source of football league ranking, something that comes from FIFA or some continental football federation website.

Would you quote any ?

Dicky Cheung · Newbie

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asian_Football_Confederation#AFC_Countries_Members_National_League_Ranking

-- Edited by Dicky Cheung on Saturday 12th of December 2009 10:51:26 AM

BonBon · Member

S-League for sure!! nothing to compare. Other than that you just gonna end up watching football league played by bunch of dwarf.

Harris · Member

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asian_Football_Confederation#AFC_Countries_Members_National_League_Ranking

Sorry, but Vleague in 7th of Asia and 1st in Asean, if I don't see wrong ?

Harris · Member

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asian_Football_Confederation#AFC_Countries_Members_National_League_Ranking

Dicky Cheung · Newbie

Try to improve your photoshop skills.

Fifa · Newbie

Current Asia's top 10 football leagues are Australia, Japan, China, South Korea, Singapore, India, Iran, United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia and Qatar.

http://www.fifa.com/worldfootball/clubfootball/news/newsid=111621.html

pirupiru · Veteran Member

which league? I think Indonesia super league :)

ahtiong · Newbie

S.League ranked number 9 in Asia so is NUMBER 2 IN ASEAN LOL...

Indonesian Super League is NUMBER ONE IN ASEAN INSTEAD.

Open your eye and read!
Asian Football Confederation

-- Edited by ahtiong on Saturday 12th of December 2009 10:38:27 PM

ahtiong · Newbie

Incase noob asking where's THE RANKING TABLE IT'S ON PAGE 7

Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia · Senior Member

P	National League	Grades
1	J. League	Grade A
2	K-League	Grade B
3	Chinese Super League	Grade B
4	Saudi Professional League	Grade B
5	UAE Football League	Grade B
6	A-League	Grade B
7	Iran Pro League	Grade B
8	Indonesian Super League	Grade B
9	S. League	Grade B
10	Uzbek League	Grade C
11	Qatar Stars League	Grade C
12	Thai Premier League	Grade C
13	V-League	Grade C
14	I-League	Grade C
15	Pakistan Premier League	Grade C
16	Syrian Premier League	Grade C
17	Jordan League	Grade D
18	Kuwaiti Premier League	Grade D
19	Super League Malaysia	Grade D
20	Hong Kong First Division League	Grade D
21	Omani League	Grade D
22	Bahraini Premier League	Grade D
23	Turkmenistan Higher League	Grade D

East Asia

Baosheng · Senior Member

All i know is that S.League is Top ten league in Asia.

Cheers..

renjuna · Newbie

huhhuuuu

Malaysia Super league is Grade D .... but wait till Kelantan FC plays in AFC ... then we can see whose high and whose low....

NgocAnhVn · Senior Member

ofcourse, all league in Asean are in top 10 of..Asean, hihi

-- Edited by NgocAnhVn on Sunday 13th of December 2009 05:49:51 AM

VNatUtrecht · Veteran Member

NgocAnhVn wrote:

ofcourse, all league in Asean are in top 10 of..Asean, hihi

-- Edited by NgocAnhVn on Sunday 13th of December 2009 05:49:51 AM

Very funny!

civileng · Member

Personally, I think that V-League is the most attractive and competitive League in Asean. We have some famous and strong clubs, such as Binh Duong, Da Nang, HAGL ..

van ariel · Member

http://www.the-afc.com/en/media-releases/26280-afc-champions-league-and-afc-cup-draw-results

AFC Champions League and AFC Cup draw results

Monday, 07 December 2009 17:51

KUALA LUMPUR: The draws for the 2010 AFC Champions League and 2010 AFC Cup group stages took place on Monday here at AFC House.

AFC Champions League 2010

THE GROUPINGS

West
Group A
Al Ahli (KSA), Al Gharafa (QAT), Al Jazira (UAE), Esteghlal (IRN)

Group B
Zobahan (IRN), Al Ittihad (KSA), Bunyodkor (UZB), Play-off Winner (West)

Group C
Al Ain (UAE), Sepahan (IRN), Al Shabab (KSA), Pakhtakor (UZB)

Group D
Al Sadd (QAT), Al Ahli (UAE), Mes (IRN), Al Hilal (KSA)

East

Group E
Seongnam Ilhwa Chunma (KOR), Melbourne Victory (AUS), Beijing Guoan (CHN), Kawasaki Frontale (JPN)

Group F
Kashima Antlers (JPN), Jeonbuk Motors (KOR), Persipura Jayapura (IDN), Changchun Yatai (CHN)

Group G
Henan Jianye (CHN), Gamba Osaka (JPN), Suwon Bluewings (KOR), Play-off East winners

Group H
Adelaide United (AUS), Shandong Luneng (CHN), Cup winners (JPN), Pohang Steelers (KOR)

Play-off draw

West
SF1 - Al Karamah (SYR) v Al Wahda (UAE)
SF2 - Churchill Brothers (IND) bye into play-off final
Final - Winner (Al Karamah v Al Wahda) v Churchill Brothers
West winner goes to ACL. The two losers go to AFC Cup.

East
SF1 - Armed Forces (SIN) v Sriwijaya (IDN)
SF2 - Da Nang (VIE) v Muangthong (THA)
Final - Winner SF1 v Winner SF2

East winner goes to ACL. The three losers go to AFC Cup.

you can see, only the persipura(indonesia), the only club from the asean could qualify automatically follow the league champion asia. followed by Sriwijaya FC (Indonesia) in the play-off rounds. other than Indonesia Super League clubs, all have passed round play-off. such as the Armed Forces (SIN), Da Nang (VIE), Muangthong (THA). in addition to afc cup, Indonesia Super League representatives are also places Persiwa (Indonesia) which qualify automatically for the AFC Cup tournament.
This proves AFC puts Indonesia as the top 10 best league in Asia which make indonesia many have escaped automatic rations to join the asia champion league and afc cup.,,.

van ariel · Member

in addition, many asean football player who played in Indonesia like a super-league national team players thailand, singapore. It means that Indonesia is a magnet league players and asean asia because of the quality and the opportunity to get a lot of money, and the competition was so tight pliers. because Indonesia is a vast country and has hundreds of soccer club

van ariel · Member

NgocAnhVn wrote:

I'm a fan of Liverpool, hihi.
About topic, as I said, V-league or Indo-league are better league for player improve their skill, but if you want to have a slot in there, you must be a skiller, hihi. So, young team is very important

u r cute.,,.ha8x,.,

arky · Member

Play in S-League... nuff said.. many players have come here and went on to play in Europe or bigger leagues outside ASEAN.

I'm not a big fan of the S-League but it does wonders for the ASEAN player..

or the ISL which is also a good league with fanatical fan following.

loveINDONESIA · Senior Member

van ariel wrote:

http://www.the-afc.com/en/media-releases/26280-afc-champions-league-and-afc-cup-draw-results
AFC Champions League and AFC Cup draw results
Monday, 07 December 2009 17:51

KUALA LUMPUR: The draws for the 2010 AFC Champions League and 2010 AFC Cup group stages took place on Monday here at AFC House.

AFC Champions League 2010

THE GROUPINGS

West
Group A
Al Ahli (KSA), Al Gharafa (QAT), Al Jazira (UAE), Esteghlal (IRN)

Group B
Zobahan (IRN), Al Ittihad (KSA), Bunyodkor (UZB), Play-off Winner (West)

Group C
Al Ain (UAE), Sepahan (IRN), Al Shabab (KSA), Pakhtakor (UZB)

Group D
Al Sadd (QAT), Al Ahli (UAE), Mes (IRN), Al Hilal (KSA)

East

Group E
Seongnam Ilhwa Chunma (KOR), Melbourne Victory (AUS), Beijing Guoan (CHN), Kawasaki Frontale (JPN)

Group F
Kashima Antlers (JPN), Jeonbuk Motors (KOR), Persipura Jayapura (IDN), Changchun Yatai (CHN)

Group G
Henan Jianye (CHN), Gamba Osaka (JPN), Suwon Bluewings (KOR), Play-off East winners

Group H
Adelaide United (AUS), Shandong Luneng (CHN), Cup winners (JPN), Pohang Steelers (KOR)

Play-off draw

West
SF1 - Al Karamah (SYR) v Al Wahda (UAE)
SF2 - Churchill Brothers (IND) bye into play-off final
Final - Winner (Al Karamah v Al Wahda) v Churchill Brothers
West winner goes to ACL. The two losers go to AFC Cup.

East
SF1 - Armed Forces (SIN) v Sriwijaya (IDN)
SF2 - Da Nang (VIE) v Muangthong (THA)
Final - Winner SF1 v Winner SF2
East winner goes to ACL. The three losers go to AFC Cup.
you can see, only the persipura(indonesia), the only club from the asean could qualify automatically follow the league champion asia. followed by Sriwijaya FC (Indonesia) in the play-off rounds. other than Indonesia Super League clubs, all have passed round play-off. such as the Armed Forces (SIN), Da Nang (VIE), Muangthong (THA). in addition to afc cup, Indonesia Super League representatives are also places Persiwa (Indonesia) which qualify automatically for the AFC Cup tournament.
This proves AFC puts Indonesia as the top 10 best league in Asia which make indonesia many have escaped automatic rations to join the asia champion league and afc cup.,,.

and also the best league in ASEAN,right?

arky · Member

The ISL just got that slot , the S-League will get that slot soon too...

orangkampung · Member

i wish Malaysia Super League standard will improve and arise together with other asean countries but with current leadership hold the power, its hopeless.. my personal opinion, Malaysia has what it takes to become among the best football league in asia.. here, we have great facilities, passionate supporters, mutinational companies to sponsor.... if our football association is smart enough, they not only can improve our football standard, but also can make alot of money from the league.. back few years ago when our league still open to foreign players, selangor was using bambang pamungkas n elie aiboy and the duo has attracted thousands indonesian supporter to come to stadium....here, we got many vietnamese, indonesians, myanmars and i believe if the right mecahnism is in place, the best player from this countries can come and play for any club in malaysia... we should import some good hand from S league to teach hw to organise professional league, learn how ISL team make a money from marketing and import thai n vietnam players to raise the standard..then, Malaysia is truly Asean

arky · Member

Malaysia Boleh!!

starboy · Veteran Member

Come ... be supporting Indonesia Sea Games champion in 2009

http://www.tinyurl.com/bismarblog

VNatUtrecht · Veteran Member

To Mod and all other members,

We've been trying to stop Starboy from spamming in every thread we have, but it turns no effect. I suspect that Starboy may be actually a program, not a real person, and it automatically spams this forum under the command of someone who has created it!

I suggest that Mod take serious action against this behavior!

FoolExposer · Veteran Member

Seriously, the ranking is a joke!

terati20 · Veteran Member

Talking about game quality and management
I think S-Leaque is the best

Talking about passion of game
Indonesia and Vietnam for sures.

Talking about most developed
Thai League

But I just wonder if you guy have information from your leagues

How many non-native player can play in a team ???

Right now ThaiLeague will start to let 5 non-native player in each team....
I think It is too much and will shut down the chance of local and youth player...

disbelief

Majapahit Kid · Senior Member

Personally 4 Asean players 2 improve,they shld venture into d korean or japanese leagues.4get d EPL nw